Everyone who knows me ALSO knows that I tend to re-watch and re-read things that I love over and over. And when life gets you down, nothing comforts like the stories we love so much. It was with that desire that I re-watched Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (probably for the 50th or 60th time) last night. And each time I re-watch or re-read something, I ALWAYS discover something new.
So, picture this scene: Harry, with the help of his friends, has outwitted, out-flown, and outsmarted each of the enchantments protecting the coveted Philosopher's Stone. While Professor Quirrell is unable to retrieve the stone from the enchanted mirror of Erised, Harry sees himself through the mirror place the stone into his pocket and, thus, the stone is transferred to him. While Harry tries to conceal the stone from Quirrel, Lord Voldemort is not fooled and knows Harry has the stone - the stone he needs to reanimate himself.
Then, Lord Voldemort does what he does best - talks. With a serpent's tongue he tries to bargain with Harry. He tells Harry that together they could bring back Harry's deceased parents, and all that Lord Voldemort requires in return is the stone. This is a tempting offer for a child who has never known his parents. Voldemort pushes Harry even further, "There is no good and evil, only power... and those too weak to seek it."
But, as the books and films have pointed out again and again, Harry has an outstanding moral character, and Harry knows that there is good and evil. There is a right and a wrong. And Harry knows that no matter how badly he wants his parents back, that death is natural and there is no way of bringing them back without committing acts of great evil. Later in the film, Dumbledore talks to Harry about Nicholas Flamel and his decision to destroy the stone. Harry remarks that without the stone and the elixir's immortal qualities that Flamel will die. Dumbledore does not seem upset about Flamel's imminent death, "Yes. He will die." In the book, Dumbledore asserts that death is a journey we all must take, "To the well-organized mind, death is but the next great adventure."
So what do we take from this? There is good and evil, and evil will always try to disguise itself as something else. Evil will challenge us daily and tempt us with the things we want most; but from this we can learn to strengthen our understanding of what it means to be good and to fight evil in all its forms.
- D.